Comments on: Rio Almost Signs – Can Fergie Make Him the Captain From Next Season? http://redrants.com/rio-almost-signs-can-fergie-make-him-the-captain-from-next-season/ Manchester United Blog Sat, 11 Feb 2012 19:42:41 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Grognard http://redrants.com/rio-almost-signs-can-fergie-make-him-the-captain-from-next-season/comment-page-1/#comment-14110 Grognard Thu, 17 Apr 2008 05:13:25 +0000 http://redrants.com/rio-almost-signs-can-fergie-make-him-the-captain-from-next-season/#comment-14110 Huntelaar is not slow. Thats a myth that is being perpetuated by a few who believe that a goal poacher is naturally slow therefore, Huntelaar must be slow. You say you have watched him play, how can you think he is slow when he constantly out paces players to the ball? And Saha on his greatest day can't shine Huntelaar's shoes. Saha never had the same kind of finishing ability. And to be frank, yes I do think you jump to conclusions on players beased on seeing them only a few times because the evidence of how good they are defeats your argument. You say you have seen Huntelaar play enough, I challenge you on that and say you haven't because had you done so, you would not honestly feel that Huntelaar lacked pace or enough of the skills necessary to be a great United player. As for Bendtner, I have seen the young man score some very nice goals for Arsenal this year and show a real goal scorers instinct by being in the right place at the right time and also showing an ability to fight for a ball in the air. You are jumping the gun on players you know very little about and you are showing a favoritism for a player most people feel is washed up and worthless in Saha. It's really not very hard to come to this conclusion about you, even if it's not correct. With all due respect, the evidence and proof backs up my evaluations. So I'll rest on this subject because it's clear we are not in agreement and will never find agreement due to a difference of opinion that we are both dead set on. There is no point. You feel you are right and I know in my heart and mind that I am. There is no middle ground here. So lets give it a rest on this subject. Huntelaar is not slow. Thats a myth that is being perpetuated by a few who believe that a goal poacher is naturally slow therefore, Huntelaar must be slow. You say you have watched him play, how can you think he is slow when he constantly out paces players to the ball? And Saha on his greatest day can’t shine Huntelaar’s shoes. Saha never had the same kind of finishing ability. And to be frank, yes I do think you jump to conclusions on players beased on seeing them only a few times because the evidence of how good they are defeats your argument. You say you have seen Huntelaar play enough, I challenge you on that and say you haven’t because had you done so, you would not honestly feel that Huntelaar lacked pace or enough of the skills necessary to be a great United player. As for Bendtner, I have seen the young man score some very nice goals for Arsenal this year and show a real goal scorers instinct by being in the right place at the right time and also showing an ability to fight for a ball in the air.

You are jumping the gun on players you know very little about and you are showing a favoritism for a player most people feel is washed up and worthless in Saha. It’s really not very hard to come to this conclusion about you, even if it’s not correct. With all due respect, the evidence and proof backs up my evaluations. So I’ll rest on this subject because it’s clear we are not in agreement and will never find agreement due to a difference of opinion that we are both dead set on. There is no point. You feel you are right and I know in my heart and mind that I am. There is no middle ground here. So lets give it a rest on this subject.

Like? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

]]> By: tevez http://redrants.com/rio-almost-signs-can-fergie-make-him-the-captain-from-next-season/comment-page-1/#comment-14107 tevez Wed, 16 Apr 2008 23:56:25 +0000 http://redrants.com/rio-almost-signs-can-fergie-make-him-the-captain-from-next-season/#comment-14107 I mentioned van nistelrooy so i was not attacking dutch imports. In fact, i said i believe huntelaar to be better than both kuyt and kezman. To make sure you don't come out and say i'm just guessing again, this is because i think huntelaar is a more natural goalscorer who takes up good positions in the box, so even playing at a higher level he will find a bit of space and score a few. He is slow, though, and physically i can't see him competing against premier league centre-halves. So i don't think he'll offer more than some tap-ins, basically. You have to weigh up his worth to the team then and i think you're better with a striker who can offer more. Saha was very strong and quick, and offered us a long option. He could run in behind and could hold up the ball, as well as chip in with goals. Btw, it's not like i've never seen huntelaar play or i've just watched videos on youtube or anything. I've seen him play, and my opinion hasn't changed at all over his style. You are not more informed than me on huntelaar. Watch a player enough and you know his game. Simple. I don't give my opinion on a player i've not seen, surely no-one does that, that's just stupid. Do you think i came to the conclusion bendtner was a bad player based solely on that one chance against us? LOL... I mentioned van nistelrooy so i was not attacking dutch imports. In fact, i said i believe huntelaar to be better than both kuyt and kezman. To make sure you don’t come out and say i’m just guessing again, this is because i think huntelaar is a more natural goalscorer who takes up good positions in the box, so even playing at a higher level he will find a bit of space and score a few. He is slow, though, and physically i can’t see him competing against premier league centre-halves. So i don’t think he’ll offer more than some tap-ins, basically. You have to weigh up his worth to the team then and i think you’re better with a striker who can offer more. Saha was very strong and quick, and offered us a long option. He could run in behind and could hold up the ball, as well as chip in with goals.
Btw, it’s not like i’ve never seen huntelaar play or i’ve just watched videos on youtube or anything. I’ve seen him play, and my opinion hasn’t changed at all over his style. You are not more informed than me on huntelaar. Watch a player enough and you know his game. Simple. I don’t give my opinion on a player i’ve not seen, surely no-one does that, that’s just stupid. Do you think i came to the conclusion bendtner was a bad player based solely on that one chance against us? LOL…

Like? Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

]]>