Connect with us

Manchester United News

Lesson to be learned from the Manchester derby

This season you can also play live, legendary football with Heineken Star Player. Play live with every UEFA Champions League match on TV and anticipate the outcome of live match moments to score. See video at the end for more information.

Now that we’ve had a few days to digest the atrocity which occurred on Sunday at Old Trafford, many solutions have been touted in order to prevent such a massacre happening in the future. However the loss itself wasn’t a massive surprise as we’ve lost our way in recent weeks and it is up to us to resurrect our season once again.

Although many people will point the finger of blame at Jonny Evans for his sending off as the beginning of our downfall, he was only partially at fault. Yes, Mario Balotelli outwitted him at the back but his dismissal was more the symptom than the cause of our loss. The main reason for our substantial defeat has been the lack of discipline by Patrice Evra.

His football, since the Champions League final of 2009, has been patchy and last Sunday, he was terribly exposed by the movement of City and David Silva’s passing. Four of the six goals conceded came from our left flank and the French left-back was neither here nor there as our rearguard simply disintegrated. The problem with left-back is, we have nobody else ready to step in for Evra. Therefore in January, we should be avidly pursuing a left-sided defender.

Besides Evra’s and Evans’ errors, the rest of our loss could be put down to pure bad luck. With Tom Cleverley unfit, we were seriously overpowered in midfield and the absence of Nemanja Vidic in central defence left an unfulfillable void in our backline. Therefore there is no need to mass panic although our Achilles heel at left-back needs immediate attention.

Before you go watch Manchester United visit Goodison Park and then host Otelul Galati at home for some Champions League action, watch Clarence Seedorf, Gianluigi Buffon, Ruud van Nistelrooy and Patrick Viera recreate some of the historic moments of the competition:

This message was brought to you by Heineken, sponsors of the UEFA Champions League, but it contains our writer’s opinion.



  1. Ahmed Yusuf Kagara

    October 27, 2011 at 11:49 am

    I trust Fergie, he will surely give me my heart desire – a total midfield clear out. Substituted with the inthing of modern football (creativity), which even a novice knows is missing in the in the present squard.

  2. Ian

    October 27, 2011 at 12:03 pm

    we should be avidly pursuing a left-sided defender

    DEFENDER being the operative word.

  3. Yang

    October 27, 2011 at 12:46 pm

    I think the biggest problem is most of player playing without thinking.

    Defensively, why nobody take care City play-maker at all? and wide player need help out in central area when you overrun in this area but nobody check this thing.

    Offensively, why keep your head smash into the stone wall? City double mark on both wide men however United keep try to force the play through wide area. I think Young can cut into central area and make things happen there is better idea.

    Evans can let Balo go why you think it is better to pull the shirt in that area? two goals down is better than reduce ten men at that time.

    So many things gone wrong All players play with their big brave heart but nobody play smart. No focus on defending and no adjustment on attacking plan too.

  4. d

    October 27, 2011 at 3:56 pm

    Scapegoats! Last season it was Carrick, season before it was Berba. I get it that some players put in bad shifts from time to time, but when multiple sites that I visit hop on the wagon it gets a bit frustrating. Evra lays it down every game, and does get caught out from time to time, but he is still United quality I can’t think of many other left backs in the premier league that would suit United better.

    • [OPTI]Madschester United

      October 27, 2011 at 4:19 pm

      Evans and Evra are on their second year of poor performances and blame is valid in my opinion.

    • tonymontanna4united

      October 27, 2011 at 8:18 pm

      Sorry mate, but have you even watched evra this season? Or last season? Or even just the city game if you cant remember his performances over such a long period, where you see he was at fault for 4, yes fookin 4, of the goals we conceeded.
      “Getting caught out time to time”, come on mate lets not be silly. Caught out several times a game, week in week out is more like it.

  5. [OPTI]Madschester United

    October 27, 2011 at 4:12 pm

    Philosophical question:

    If Qatar had bought United back in 2005 (i.e. no Glazer) and spent like Man City, would we as fans be dancing if we conquered Europe and dominated the EPL????

    • tonymontanna4united

      October 27, 2011 at 8:14 pm

      Yes of course we would mate. Because at the end of the day, we’d know that everything we had achieved, was a result of our own hard work, and most importantly, our own bloody money. We dont need a big wealthy arabian, chinaman, russian etc to come in and pump billions into the club to make us successful. We just need to rid ourselves of the debt, and be able to spend OUR OWN MONEY on the team, rather than pissing it away to pay off debts for parasites we never wanted here in the first place.
      So a bit different to city and chelski, who would owe all their achievements to some billionaire who propelled them up the league because they were his new little play thing.

  6. Grognard

    October 27, 2011 at 6:31 pm

    I had to just laugh out loud when I read this ridiculous article and the even more ridiculous quotes from Scholes. Newsflash Scholesy, it is rotation that has created this mess in the first place. Yet another sample of commentary from the dumbest and lowest members of the food chain, footballers. Unfuckingbelievable! 🙄 🙄

    • [OPTI]Madschester United

      October 27, 2011 at 8:02 pm

      what’s this to do with Scholes? I thought the piece was actually pretty good, except Cleverley’s dynamic influence is understated.

  7. [OPTI]Madschester United

    October 27, 2011 at 8:11 pm

    For Everton game, I would pick:
    ———– Gea ———-
    Fabio – Smalling-Vidic-Fryatt
    Nani – Anderson – Cleverly- Young
    —–Rooney -Berba ——-

    Subs: Chicharito, Welbeck, Fletcher, Vally, Jones, Evra, Lindegaard

    • tonymontanna4united

      October 27, 2011 at 8:35 pm

      For me it’d be:

      ——–De Gea——–

      Subs: Lindegaard, Fabio, Anderson, Giggs, Morrison, Welbeck, Rooney.

      Quite a few players missing there from my first team, but as ive said before, if the city game did anything, it should show the rest of the squad that nobody, and i mean nobody, should take their place for granted.
      So evra and rio miss out on the 1st team and the squad in general for obvious reasons, whilst rooney, yes rooney, also misses out for the simple reason that his form has sucked now for a few weeks, because he too needs to learn he is not undroppable either, and also because i cant remember the last time he had a good game, or scored against everton. 2007 in the 4-2 win is the last i remember.
      So a bit controversial there but berba needs his chance, and this could be the chance he needs.
      The backline i think picks itself really, with fryers the obvious surprise inclusion there. Just think the boy deserves his chance really, so with evras shocking form it has to be between him and fabio, and with fabio being reverted to more of a RB, i have to go with young zeki. A big decision here, but the boy deserves his chance, alot more than evra anyway whose had enough chances to last him a lifetime.
      As for the midfield, pretty obvious really apart from my inclusion of carrick.
      Yes the dreaded carrick, the man i have gone on about constantly for about the last 3 years starts for my team. And why? Well for the simple reason that he’s more withdrawn than fletcher, and whilst i think his shielding of the back 4 isnt as good as some like to make out, i think its probably better him playing than fletcher.
      And after last weeks horrendous lack of help from the midfield i have to go with him.
      Up top ive already explained berbatov, and it has to be hernandez also with me, as i think against evertons rather slow, mistake prone defence, there’ll be plenty of gaps for him to exploit.
      As for the bench, pretty obvious really apart from one name, ravel morrison. Have been raving about this lad for bloody ages now, he deserves his chance as far as im concerned. Even 10 mins would do him a world of good.

      Anyway sorry for going on, just think this weeks team selection will be crucial in deciding which direction the PL trophy will be heading this year. If fergie really keeps persisting with the likes of rio and evra again and again, well, i have to say i really do fear the way this club could be headed, as what sort of message does that send out.

      • [OPTI]Madschester United

        October 27, 2011 at 9:29 pm

        I can live with this lineup, though I am a bit scared by Jones-Smalling combo. Too unruly.

        We should beat this team convincingly.

        And sorry about the mislabeling of Ezekiel Fryers (Amish 😆 ) as Fryatt. 😳

        • tonymontanna4united

          October 27, 2011 at 9:46 pm

          Yeah i can see what your saying, but i just think fabio might be a bit rash at times, and he does have a habit of wandering all over the place and leaving lots of space behind him.
          Jones is quite similar too but i think due to his natural position being CB, hes still a bit more disciplined than his brazilian team mate.
          Other than that though the rest of the team should pick itself.
          Its good to see though were both agreeing on “fryatt” 😉 a very good player, who ive been cheering for to make his first team debut properly for a good few weeks now. Think he could be thrown in on saturday, even in a red hot atmosphere against a very decent team, and still do a very good job (10 times better than evra anyway). Plus its always nice to see one of our own make it up through the ranks.

        • [OPTI]Madschester United

          October 28, 2011 at 3:49 am

          Fryatt sounds better than Ezekiel Fryers… seriously. Ezekiel Fryer is surely an Amish farmer name 😀

  8. [OPTI]Madschester United

    October 27, 2011 at 8:12 pm

    I’ve decided that ONLY if we win the title #20 this year AND beat City at Wastelands, will I be able to get over the Derby crushing.

  9. Spizzy

    October 28, 2011 at 5:29 am

    For me im waiting to see the decisions that’ll be made this week.
    The defeat to shitty just made fergie’s decision at anfield seem even more brainless.What was the thinking?shouldn’t a sane man try to win every game and let the next game handle itself. I can understand when it’s competition, like resting players against swansea when planning to play milan in europe but the last three games have been a series of bad decisions. Let’s have a go at all games because nothing’s guaranteed in this life n try to win from the 1st minute not the 70th.we can rest players when the game is won.

    • tonymontanna4united

      October 28, 2011 at 4:14 pm

      Yeah, gonna be very interesting with the team selection this week. Infact id go as far as to say depending on the team sheet we put out, even ahead of the result, will define which direction the title will be heading this year.
      Because to me, it will speak volumes if we go with evra and rio again. It will tell me player power rules, that there are indeed certain members of the squad who are undroppable, and it will also raise questions as to fergie, and the way he runs the team.
      So id go as far as to say, the future of this club, and the direction it is going in, will be decided before a ball has even been kicked on saturday lunchtime.

  10. godzilla

    October 28, 2011 at 7:16 am

    When we sold JOS i had said, it might have been better to sell Evra and fit JOS at LB. He was much more disciplined and better defensively than Evra is these days. Hell Evra makes that enrique guy look better these days.

  11. thatboywazza

    October 28, 2011 at 12:29 pm

    For Everton game, I would pick:
    ———– Gea ———-
    Jones – Smalling-Vidic-Fryers
    Valencia – Carrick – Cleverly- Park
    —–Rooney -Berba ——-

    Subs: Chicharito, Nani, Fletcher, Young, Fabio, Evra, Lindegaard

    • tonymontanna4united

      October 28, 2011 at 4:23 pm

      Seems the majority of us are agreed that we no longer want to see rio nor evra involved in 1st team affairs for the forseeable future. That we also all want to see smalling played centrally next to vida, with any 2 of jones, fabio or fryers being preferred at full back.
      That alot of us would also like to see berba getting back in the team, or even squad again, and treated with a bit of god damn respect.
      That we want a bloody big shake up, so as all the players realise nobody, and i mean nobody, regardless of their experience, value, or name/reputation, is a guaranteed starter anymore, whose poor performances will be overlooked because of what theyve done for the club in the past.
      Well there you go fergie, the fans have spoken. Now show us your the same mean ass, take no shit, winner that doesnt tolerate mediocrity from anyone and show us this with your selections this saturday.

  12. thatboywazza

    October 28, 2011 at 12:42 pm

    The way Evra is playing now reminds of oh how a certain frenchie (Le Blanc used to play for united).He was productive offensively but defensively he left us fooked.I love Evra to bits but he needs some R n R or something,surgery even???? Somehow he became complacent or foolish or simply borderline destructive to the teams chances.As for Evans he needs time out on loan again or something.He makes a shit load of mistakes time and time again.What puzzles me right is how fergie plays a player like evans who has i dont know how many red cards and yellow cards in his short career over a much better player.The Rolls royce of Defenders (Phil Jones).He has committed like one foul or something in like 500 plus minutes.Thats astonishing for any defensive player let alone any football player!!!!.

    PS:Rio you lost your right to your title.Its like his playing with an injury and carrying a 40 pound load on his back at the sametime.His football has been atrocious.He has lost his defensive and ball playing abilities.He is worse than John Oshea was and he wasnt half as talented as Rio

    • tonymontanna4united

      October 28, 2011 at 4:35 pm

      Yeah i agree. Rio, evans and evra, none of them should be anywhere near the 1st team on current form.
      Evans should have been bloody sold last summer, rio has been too much into his “celebrity” lifestyle to care at the minute it seems, and evra, well where do i start with him. Fryers should be promoted to the 1st team squad for the forseeable future, and evra in turn should drop down and fill in for fryers with the reserve team. See how he gets on playing in front of 200 people in the pishing rain in bury on a swamp. About all he deserves really.
      We should be looking to january now and doing whatever is possible to make their vacations from the first team, permanent. Offer evans in a swap for gary cahill at bolton. Ok not the best player in the world but 3/4 levels above evans right now, still young, and going for a song.
      Leave evra in the reserves until the summer, when he can bugger off to milan, madrid (obviously not real, athletico is about his level) or where ever it was he wanted to go 2 years ago, and use the money to bring in baines, izaguirre or someone as his replacement.
      Rio, i suppose id keep around, merely for his experience, and he could still be useful for the odd home league game, in the cups. Hes only got a year to run anyway after this season, so id keep him around til then i think, but his days in the 1st team against the big boys are well and truely over now.
      That’d then leave us with a pretty solid backline, attack and goal. Then we’d just need to sort out our midfield with tiote and someone else coming in and we’d be sorted.

      • Grognard

        October 28, 2011 at 7:59 pm

        Despite those three sucking badly, the real problem is the constant rotation of the back four which does not allow any of them to settle in and get comfortable with their partners. Yes I understand that injuries have brought this on but Fergie still likes to play around with Evans and Smalling when everything is fine and I for one am sick of it. I want an answer to the question of the Twins. What are their futures knowing full well they are inconsistent and often injured? I want Fergie to finally acknowledge the poor play of Evra by punishing him, not starting him and offering him the captain’s armband which for me is a disgrace. This muppet needs to be sold yesterday, not in January. I’d release him before I let him pollute the pitch and the dressing room with his questionable attitude and terrible play.

        As for Evans, I’m sure Brucey could use another United alumni. Ship him off before he destroys our season with his propensity to get yellow and red cards on a game or bi-weekly basis not to mention giving up a penalty almost every time he starts. Slight exaggeration for effect but I’m sure you get my drift. Fergie must decide when it comes to Jone and Smalling who plays CB and who is RB and stick with that. Rio should be sold or forced to retire simply because he can no longer be counted on. I disagree about his lifestyle being the reason for his poor form. Poor conditioning and form is due to months and or weeks in the infirmary dealing with his back problem and the odd foot or leg problem and this has caused him to lose a step and his edge, not to mention his confidence. As for Vidic, well he needs to know he has a partner to count on and who will stick around game after game. When this doesn’t happen he tends to try to do too much and this gets him in trouble and then the yellows and reds start popping up.

        Finally, one more factor that needs to be addressed in regards to improving our back four and thus our goal allowance ratio is that De Gea needs to start to communicate better with his back four. Like Schmeichel and EVDS, he needs to shout and direct them better and when they screw up he needs to lay into them so that they realize they screwed up. He is too tame and too tentative right now and he needs to at least start barking orders better.

        Oh and one more thing. Fergie needs to find a way of keeping Evra from moving out of position so much. Jones does this a bit too but he seems to get back fast enough and tries harder to defend. Evra is just ball watching and he cuts into our own box way too much which always leaves his man wide open on the far post. I’m frankly sick of seeing this game in and game out. Is it too much to ask him to stop playing like Nani with no skill and to play LB?

  13. tonymontanna4united

    October 28, 2011 at 4:58 pm

    On this day in 1972, the “holy trinity” of best, law and charlton played their last game together.
    Absolute legends the lot of them, would have given anything to see the 3 of them in their pomp, in the same team.

    • Grognard

      October 28, 2011 at 7:37 pm

      Well there are always a few dvd alternatives or YouTube. I feel your pain mate. They were a terrific trio and Best for one is a player I could watch all day long without blinking.

  14. Grognard

    October 28, 2011 at 7:43 pm

    So what can we expect tomorrow vs Everton at the unfriendly Goodison Park? Expect a cowardly lion once again showing up and hoping for a 1-0 win or a draw and only creating a few true scoring chances while trying to keep the damage Everton create to a bare minimum. I expect nothing new, nothing impressive and certainly nothing to appease the fans. This is a road game after all at a venue where we traditionally don’t do so well or at least do not play our best. There have been moments over the years but United coming off their worst and most humiliating loss in recent memory has got to have had an affect on their confidence and morale. Lets see what Fergie can conjure up. Sorry but personally, I expect very little and I will be clicking my heels in joy if we steal a point. Anything greater will have me dancing in the streets, provided it’s not raining here in Vancouver. And there’s small chance of that not happening. Prediction for the match? 1-1 with us scoring late to steal a point.

  15. colver

    October 28, 2011 at 7:48 pm

    The article is a bit generous to the other ten players on the pitch! City outclassed us in every single position on the pitch. Perhaps Pat’s dodgy defending and Evan’s sending off inflated the scoreline but City exposed us the same way Barcelona did earlier this year.

    Defensive ill-discipline is endemic in our team. Whatever happened to the stingy team who denied Barcelona a goal over 180 minutes? We are way too open as a team. So it is easy for a side like City at the top of their game to pick out the holes just as Barcelona did.

    Neither Anderson or Fletcher did much defending and consequently our defence was under constant siege so it was only a matter of time before someone made a slip. But worse Anderson and Fletcher were completely non-productive on the ball once City shut down the flanks. The middle was wide open in the first half hour and both Fletcher and Anderson had the chance to get very far forward but they were completely incapable of creating even a single chance!

    Also same as with Barcelona earlier this year we had no answer to City’s movement and when Silva started to cut inside no-one had any idea how to deal with that.

    We have a young defence and they are going to make mistakes. But if they are given zero protection it just makes their job that much harder.

    Here in my opinion are the lessons to be learnt

    1. If you come up against a team with a better midfield do not allow yourself to be outnumbered even at home. Against the Manchester City’s Real Madrid’s Bayern Munich’s and Barcelona’s of the world we need to play three in the middle.

    2. Agree that Evra needs replacing. In an ideal world I would also buy a right back because neither Smalling and Jones are natural right backs and the twins are incapable of staying fit. Freezing Brown out and selling him was a major boner move.

    3. As Jay Wire pointed out if you are playing two in the middle one has to be defensive the other needs to be offensive. As Fletcher has forgotten how to defend that pretty much means that Carrick has to be a permanent fixture in the team accompanied by one of Cleverley or Anderson, with preference to Cleverley who is already miles ahead of Anderson.

    4. We do not play well at a slow tempo. We beat City in the Community Shield playing high tempo blood and guts football. Sunday was played at a snail’s pace and that played right into City’s hands. Of course it was partly because they shut down the wings which is where we have the most pace. But also we turned up looking flat, tired, burnt out and uninspired. United teams never play well at anything less than 100%. And we were not giving 100% out there. City were the hungrier team. They deserved to win. Interestingly it was the last season or two I started to notice this trend of regular flat performances. It is very disturbing to me that players are not capable of firing themselves up for every game.

    5) But also the problem is we didn’t have a Plan B. The only players we have capable of playing well in a slow game are Berbatov and Giggs. Absolutely no-one else. Our side is majorly unbalanced in that respect. For slow games you need to be strong defensively and have a creative midfielder who can unlock a defence. We have neither of those things.

    • Grognard

      October 28, 2011 at 8:07 pm

      Totally agree with all your points made and especially the part about us playing slow and not up tempo. We at our core are an up tempo team. When you have players like Rooney, Nani, Young and our fast fullbacks, to play a slow and methodical game defeats the purpose of what our positive3s and strengths are. Problem with us playing up tempo is that even though we score goals, we are caught often in the counter attack and we give them up. But here’s the thing. Last week we were not playing up tempo and in fact were sloth like and we still gave up a ton of goals. So if I am going to go down fighting, let it be at full speed and I’ll take my chances that our skill players can give us what we need to win.

      As for the need of three midfielders, at present I agree, but if we were to sign either a great defensive midfielder or a great attacking one, then I still believe that two is fine but we need to get ourr team in attacking mode which keeps a great opponent respecting us and fearing goals against. Presently I feel Cleverley is a risk worth taking as our attacking midfielder so for me the duty in January is to buy that dominating defensive midfielder because frankly I have no faith in Carrick, Fletcher or Anderson. And as I see it, if Pogba was really as good as they say, he would have already made a claim to start and not just highlight in the Carling Cup. He’s obviously a few years away and we cannot afford to wait for him.

  16. colver

    October 28, 2011 at 8:17 pm

    Agree Grognard. Cleverley’s all round game is good enough for him to be a more than adequate attacking midfielder. And while I have little faith in Anderson maybe if given enough games in his preferred position of attacking midfield he could do a job for us and then we can reassess in summer if it is worthwhile getting an attacking midfielder/playmaker. But most definitely we need a defensive midfielder to protect our vulnerable backline until players like Smalling and Jones mature.

    Hansen is not the most objective commentator out there. But I respect his judgement when it comes to defenders. And he argues that Smalling and Jones simply don’t have the positioning yet. It will come with time. But until then they need protection.

  17. Grognard

    October 28, 2011 at 10:00 pm

    More revelations of Glazer greed and mismanagement surface in this month’s newsletter from MUST. Read it and weep.

    “[1] Revealed: Glazers’ secretly charged United 16.1m in “management fees”

    “[2] Sir Alex Ferguson – your help needed to celebrate 25 glorious years.”

    “[1] Revealed: Glazers’ secretly charged United 16.1m in “management fees”

    “… and they’ve personally bought more than $10m of the bonds too so now our club is also personally paying them interest on their debt that they have dumped on our club. As one Red on Twitter said “And we thought it was only City who were taking the **** out of us this week”.

    “We wanted all MUST members to see this story (below) as it highlights much of what is wrong about the Glazer takeover of our football club.”

    “It’s clear that these details were intentionally hidden from supporters and were only revealed when the club adopted new accounting rules in preparation for the possible flotation in Singapore. It does beg the question what else is being hidden from supporters? Where did the money come from to pay off the PIKs? Were they just refinanced and the facts hidden in Delaware USA?”

    “The accounts also revealed that Kevin Glazer, who is a non-executive member of the club’s board of directors, and his immediate family own $10.6m worth of the club’s bonds. Those bonds pay an interest interest rate of 8.375 per cent – meaning our club is now not only paying interest on their debt but actually now paying interest to Glazer family members on part of their debt that they landed on our club.”

    “It’s shameful that the FA and government did not have any regulations in place to stop the Glazer takeover or the foresight to block the takeover going through and protect supporters from this type of exploitation.”

    “We’ll be following up with a further message to MPs next week and we hope all UK based United fans will use the opportunity to contact their MP to show how important football ownership and governance is to supporters.”

    “It’s now calculated that the total cost of the Glazers’ ownership of the club since their takeover has come to £532m.”

    “That’s almost seven Ronaldo’s.”

    The Full Figures can be viewed on this link.

    The Score
    Friday 28 October 2011
    United paid Glazer family over £16.1m in management fees

    “FIGURES RELEASED BY Manchester United for the financial year ended 30 June 2011 have shown that the club has paid its owners, the Glazer family, over £16.1m in three years in “management fees”.”

    “The Glazer family were paid fees of £6m for the 2011 financial year, £4.325m in 2010, and a little under £3m in 2009.”

    “SLP Partners – a company also controlled by the Glazer family – was also paid £2.9m in consultancy fees in 2010.”

    “United were not obliged to disclose the payments under previous accounting rules, and had accordingly opted not to do so.”

    “However, the change in Premier League financial rules meant they were subsequently forced to publicly own up to these figures.”

    “The new figures mean the total cost of the Glazers’ ownership of the club since their takeover has come to £532m. By comparison, the dividend payments prior to their takeover, between 1991 and 2005, amounted to £62.6million.”

    “The accounts also reveal that Kevin Glazer, who is a non-executive member of the club’s board of directors, and his immediate family own $10.6m worth of the club’s bonds – essentially a form of IOU which allows it to borrow cash from investors.”

    “Those bonds pay an interest interest rate of 8.375 per cent – meaning Kevin’s family earned £379,180 in interest from the club last year.”

    “The family have consistently come under criticism from United supporters after they borrowed hundreds of millions of pounds to finance their purchase of United in 2005 – and then transferred that debt to the club, which had been debt-free before then.”

    “Ticket prices were increased by over 42 per cent following their takeover, which led fans to protest against the owners.”

    • Moscow is my heaven

      October 28, 2011 at 11:23 pm

      Love United Hate Glazer

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Manchester United News